NAF World Headquarters :: View topic - NAF World Cup Results by Round

NAF World Headquarters

NAF World Cup - NAF World Cup Results by Round - *** Please Review ***

Old_Man_Monkey - Oct 24, 2007 - 03:23 AM
Post subject: NAF World Cup Results by Round - *** Please Review ***

The NAF World Cup staff would like for each coach to review the Match Results by Round for any errors or ommissions.

Please do NOT report Table errors - many matches were switched to balance the teams and the information is not critical. What ARE critical are the results: race, opponent, TDs and CAS... please review these results carefully. This list will remain available for at least ten (10) days so that coaches can review the list.

Please report any concerns via email to Ian Williams at:

doubleskulls@gmail.com

and CC to Lycos (Dave Downes) and me.

Again as always, thanks to everyone for making this weekend so magical and so special.
I trust and hope that everyone has returned home safely... until we see each other again.

Jim L.
OMM

Marco_Gianni - Oct 24, 2007 - 04:32 AM
Post subject: RE: NAF World Cup Results by Round - *** Please Review ***

everything's ok for me... Wink

Cheers OMM !

Hangus - Oct 24, 2007 - 04:34 AM
Post subject: RE: NAF World Cup Results by Round - *** Please Review ***

Mine is fine i think (never kept a true record of cas though Smile

)

Darktroll - Oct 24, 2007 - 05:17 AM
Post subject: RE: NAF World Cup Results by Round - *** Please Review ***

All is OK for me...

Just my firstname which is "Nicolas" and no "Nicholas" Very Happy

A great thanks to you, OMM, to Lycos, and all orgas... Wink

It was really wonderful !!

Kheldar - Oct 24, 2007 - 06:47 AM
Post subject: RE: NAF World Cup Results by Round - *** Please Review ***

All games correct for me.

Lizardcore - Oct 24, 2007 - 07:39 AM
Post subject: RE: NAF World Cup Results by Round - *** Please Review ***

Every games ok for me :

FBB Laurent David (Lizardcore) Skaven

Thanks a lot for everything, it will be hard to play in a norma tounrament after that amazing one...

Thanks also for stripping our medals from Fumbbl Team hands...

Maybe we'll meet at toronto next time ?!

Ryan - Oct 24, 2007 - 08:46 AM
Post subject: RE: NAF World Cup Results by Round - *** Please Review ***

Every Games OK for me as well

I'll ask my Mate to check over it when I see him

Longshot - Oct 24, 2007 - 09:41 AM
Post subject: RE: NAF World Cup Results by Round - *** Please Review ***

all is good for me.

Toronto seems nice to me Liz Wink

ninjahamster - Oct 24, 2007 - 11:15 AM
Post subject:

All games correct for me (ninjahamster - jimmy balderstone)

I do notice that you have my team-mates team wrong - Richard Hogan (Grotsmeg) was using Chaos, not Chaos Dwarves.

Kithor - Oct 25, 2007 - 01:30 AM
Post subject:

Seems alright from my side. Razz

Kithor - Oct 25, 2007 - 01:35 AM
Post subject:

OMM could you please post a link to the individual standings? Very Happy

I hadn't the chance to take a look as we left after the award ceremony. Wink

Old_Man_Monkey - Oct 25, 2007 - 02:25 AM
Post subject:

Kithor - we will do this after everyone has reviewed the round by round information and the coaches data, my friend.... Ian sent these sheets along so we could put them up while he returns with his family to Australia... Lycos also is on holiday and he has the raw data sheets so once they are checked versus any information posted or emailed, we will post a DRAFT finish. All of this is preparation for the mammoth task of entering this tournament into the NAF ranking system....

OMM

antipixi - Oct 25, 2007 - 02:50 AM
Post subject:

Mine are correct (unfortunately!). I'll get my teams results from them and check them ASAP. (Most of them are rubbish at checking forums!)

Kithor - Oct 25, 2007 - 03:10 AM
Post subject:

Ok, thanks for the information. Smile

Cheers

Kithor

Jokaero - Oct 25, 2007 - 04:42 AM
Post subject:

looks alright to me Smile

Best Swiss Coach @WC
Jokaero

(okok, I was the only one)

Marco_Gianni - Oct 25, 2007 - 06:09 AM
Post subject:

And, as the best swiss coach you deserve a ... chocolate medal !

Thanks for our match Wink

Turin - Oct 25, 2007 - 06:32 AM
Post subject:

Well, my last match is not correct. I won 2-1 (actually my opponent, Laurent, rolled many awful dice, so it would have been a wonder if he had won it after all, although he played a good game under these circumstances...). However, I've already written an e-mail yesterday, but haven't gut your adress and Lyco's.

Tristelune - Oct 25, 2007 - 10:33 AM
Post subject:

All good for me Very Happy

Hudson - Oct 25, 2007 - 01:50 PM
Post subject:

All good for me, best Cornish coach. Do i get a pastie?

Heroic_Tackle - Oct 25, 2007 - 02:54 PM
Post subject:

Mine are OK.

Frikipe - Oct 26, 2007 - 03:10 AM
Post subject: Re: RE: NAF World Cup Results by Round - *** Please Review *

Hello all the games ok for me,

Now 2 little things:

First thanks to all the people on the staff doing this tournament posible we have a great time and lots of fun.

Second :

Lizardcore wrote:

FBB Laurent David (Lizardcore) Skaven

Thanks also for stripping our medals from Fumbbl Team hands...
!

In the ceremony when Jim announce the third place the fact that nobody shouts and claims for the prize and my limited English understanding makes me think that Jim said fbbles instead fbb france. And nobody strip the medals from our hands, we have talk to Jim as soon as we saw the stands and notice our error.

Finally just give my excuses to the staff and anybody offended with this.

Best regards, Frikipe.

Haktar - Oct 26, 2007 - 03:36 AM
Post subject:

Hi my round 7 (table Skavenblight 110) againt Navarre is not correct :
I score twice.
So the result is draw, the score is 2-2 (0 casuality for navarre, and 1 for me) and not 2-1 as indicated.

Old_Man_Monkey - Oct 26, 2007 - 07:35 AM
Post subject: Re: RE: NAF World Cup Results by Round - *** Please Review *

frikipe wrote:

Second :

Lizardcore wrote:

FBB Laurent David (Lizardcore) Skaven

Thanks also for stripping our medals from Fumbbl Team hands...
!

So EVERYONE knows: The mistake of announcing the 3rd place team was mine and mine alone - when the FBB team did not respond, I thought that I had misread the notes from Ian and when I looked at Frikipe, I could tell he was not sure either. The error was mine and I am the ONLY one reponsible - Frikipe and the rest of the FUMBBL Esp team were complete gentleman and very gracious - they came to me when the results were posted and offered to return their medals. Their grace and sportsmanship were perfect, and their understanding of the error was among the finest sports gestures I've ever witnessed. I will forever be grateful to this team for their help and sportsmanship at a time where they could have caused dissent and tension and marred an otherwise beautiful event - they have my eternal thanks.

I am sure David did not mean any slight with his post - I believe his team is grateful that the error was corrected so quickly and that the team's medals are headed to their rightful home. But everyone should give a tip of respect to Team FUMBBL's handling of the situation and their perfect conduct during and after the ceremony.

Jim Lanier
Old Man Monkey

KaduC - Oct 26, 2007 - 07:59 AM
Post subject:

My results are correct.
FBB François Huguet (Kadu-C), Norse

Thanks for your job Jim and all organizers of course. Wink

Frikipe - Oct 26, 2007 - 10:10 AM
Post subject: Re: RE: NAF World Cup Results by Round - *** Please Review *

Old_Man_Monkey wrote:

frikipe wrote:

Second :

Lizardcore wrote:

FBB Laurent David (Lizardcore) Skaven

Thanks also for stripping our medals from Fumbbl Team hands...
!

Thank you Jim, just give you my excuses becouse i think it was my mistake. The world cup '07 was amazing and all of you did a great job.

CoffinDodger - Oct 26, 2007 - 10:18 AM
Post subject: RE: Re: RE: NAF World Cup Results by Round - *** Please Revi

Hi all,

My results are all fine too - Many thanks to all those I played against - you were all great sports (Especially Marco!)

BFN

Paul

Doubleskulls - Oct 27, 2007 - 03:05 AM
Post subject:

Just a marker to let you know that everything up to here has been updated (not in Jim's online version though).

ZFurelli - Oct 27, 2007 - 03:28 PM
Post subject:

Result are all fine - just the surname spelling incorrect.

Furelli

Marco_Gianni - Oct 28, 2007 - 05:32 AM
Post subject: Re: RE: NAF World Cup Results by Round - *** Please Review *

Old_Man_Monkey wrote:

I am sure David did not mean any slight with his post - I believe his team is grateful that the error was corrected so quickly and that the team's medals are headed to their rightful home. But everyone should give a tip of respect to Team FUMBBL's handling of the situation and their perfect conduct during and after the ceremony.

Jim Lanier
Old Man Monkey

As I've told my compatriots since the beginning : that was obviously an involontary misunderstanding. Actually, I didn't even notice the mistake during the ceremony... And when I did, the medals were already given back. So no offense at all, we all know that the Fumbbl team is composed by great coaches with a really good spirit Smile

Hope we'll see you soon ! Wink

DonShula - Oct 28, 2007 - 05:20 PM
Post subject:

Everything is OK for me (Gégé in the Old School team, but DFC in fact! Very Happy

)

Shaniepoo1 - Oct 29, 2007 - 01:31 AM
Post subject:

I thought i won every game 2-0...?

As far as i can tell everything is fine.

Doubleskulls - Oct 29, 2007 - 06:44 AM
Post subject:

Done up to here

Navarre - Oct 29, 2007 - 04:27 PM
Post subject:

Looks good to me, 7th game score is alittle questionable maybe, the ref called time but the person I was playing refused to stop and then insisted on playing for another twenty mintues after time had been called. The NAF Offical took away the score card and filled it in himself so if he decided the game was over at 2-1 i'm not going to argue, I finished all my other games in sound time.

Nav

Haktar - Oct 30, 2007 - 07:47 AM
Post subject:

Navarre wrote:

The score was 2-2 on the 14th turn when the referee come. We play only 2 turn after, and i quite mark a third td (but a failed the reception).
So the score was 2-2 and could be 3-2 for me if i succeed my last action, not 2-1 for you.
Maybe the referee didn't understand well, i don't know what happen.
Maybe you don't remember well the match?
For my part i didn't say the result to the referee.
You play untill the last turn, and i never insisted to play.

Valen - Nov 01, 2007 - 04:35 AM
Post subject:

Ian,

I used wood elves in round 2 not dwarves mate

Petew - Nov 06, 2007 - 11:13 AM
Post subject:

all good for me!

Pete Woodroffe - PeteW - Sudbury Club

Doubleskulls - Nov 07, 2007 - 03:47 AM
Post subject:

Done to here

Flix - Nov 09, 2007 - 01:58 AM
Post subject:

Question: some coaches wont have 9 games
Nick Games
Phobos 8
grimlock180 8
Maso 7
Valen 7
Panico 6
Rab 6
butch 6
dpwright 6
Blackrose 5
Paul Forest 5
Venomous Breath 3
Longfang 2
Lycos 1
Darkson 1

ps read out the games and calculated a list: won - tie - lost of each coach

Kool - Nov 09, 2007 - 02:50 AM
Post subject:

I think if you looked at the referee list you would be able to see a coincidence Wink

Panico - Nov 09, 2007 - 02:51 AM
Post subject:

Flix, most of them are ref (ie, me, darkson, lycos, Valen, Longfang, Venomous Breath), so we shared some teams in order to fill all the odd spots, having so different numbers of games...
Some of them just arrived on saturday for the team tournament because they were at work on friday (ie Rab and others), some arrive late on friday and missed a a game or two the first day...(ie Maso and others)... so basically it's all right.

But, as I don't know all the names on the list, we have to check if we forget to insert some match...

Lycos - Nov 09, 2007 - 03:32 AM
Post subject:

The only two I am concerned about are Phobos and Blackrose. They are each missing one game. The 3 with 6 are the Blighty Crusader School teachers who couldnt get Friday off work. There are some there who came late. Just about the rest of us are refs who filled in to match numbers as best we could.

However those two should have 9 and 6 games so I will be checking that. Thanks Flix

Valen - Nov 10, 2007 - 02:53 PM
Post subject:

Grimlock180 is one of the cornish lads, and I wasnt aware of any of them missing a game

Lycos - Nov 11, 2007 - 03:01 PM
Post subject:

Yeah I should have posted that Gav, there are 4 games that I cant find. Working on it.

slup - Jan 11, 2008 - 02:34 AM
Post subject:

Valen wrote:

Ian,

I used wood elves in round 2 not dwarves mate

Is corrected now.
The match still shows as Dvarf but the rating for the match affects your wood elf rating.